Facts: Bharat Kumar was arrested after 484 litres of codeine-based cough syrup were recovered from a pickup van in Khagaria, Bihar. He argued that he was merely standing near the vehicle and had no connection with the seized substance. He also contended that the preparation contained codeine below the prescribed permissible concentration.

Issue: Whether cough syrup containing codeine within the exemption limits under the Central Government notification could be treated as contraband under the NDPS Act.

Decision: Justice Ashok Kumar Pandey granted bail and observed that qualifying codeine preparations containing not more than 100 mg per dosage unit and not exceeding 2.5% concentration, subject to the other conditions of the notification, fall outside the relevant NDPS prohibition. Such regulatory violations may instead attract the Drugs and Cosmetics Act.

Also Read – Most Important Allahabad High Court Judgments of October 2026

Facts: The petitioner, a 14-year-old child at the time of the alleged incident, was accused of sexually assaulting a three-year-old girl under Section 65(2) of the BNS, 2023, and Sections 4 and 8 of the POCSO Act. The Juvenile Justice Board rejected his bail application, and the appellate court upheld the rejection.

Issue: Whether bail could be denied to a child in conflict with law when the exceptions under Section 12 of the Juvenile Justice Act, 2015, were not established.

Decision: Justice Arun Kumar Jha set aside the lower courts’ orders and granted bail. The Court emphasised that rehabilitation and reformation are central to juvenile justice and institutionalisation should be a last resort. Bail was granted subject to parental supervision and regular court attendance.

Also Read – Most Important Madras High Court Judgments of October 2026

Facts: A wife challenged the Family Court’s dismissal of her divorce petition. She alleged physical and mental cruelty and claimed that her husband had concealed the true extent of his financial resources. The husband disclosed substantially lower income than the assets claimed by the wife. To resolve the financial dispute, the High Court appointed a Special Officer to investigate his properties.

Issue: Whether the High Court could appoint a Special Officer to examine the husband’s assets and determine appropriate permanent alimony.

Decision: A Division Bench of Justice Bibek Chaudhuri and Justice Rana Vikram Singh granted divorce under the applicable Divorce Act, 1869, and awarded ₹50 lakh as permanent alimony. The Court relied on the Special Officer’s report, which revealed property worth approximately ₹4 crore, and directed payment within three months.

Also Read – Most Important Punjab and Haryana High Court Judgments of October 2026

Facts: The case concerned land acquired for widening NH-82. Dissatisfied with the compensation, the landowners approached the Additional Collector, Gaya, who was appointed as arbitrator in 2017. During the pending arbitration, the Central Government issued another notification on 21 June 2018 appointing the Divisional Commissioner as arbitrator. The Additional Collector subsequently passed an award on 4 August 2018, treating the disputed land as developing land. The Corporation challenged the award and sought transfer of the proceedings.

Issue: Whether the subsequent notification could displace an arbitrator already conducting pending proceedings and whether the compensation award was legally sustainable.

Decision: The Patna High Court held that the 2018 notification operated prospectively and did not affect pending proceedings. However, it set aside the compensation-related directions and ordered reassessment of compensation, including solatium and interest, within three months.

Facts: The company participated in a tender floated by the Bihar Rural Works Department and was declared the lowest bidder (L-1). Subsequently, the authorities disqualified it because the stamp papers used for affidavits were not purchased in the names of the persons making them. However, this requirement was not mentioned in the Notice Inviting Tender (NIT). The company challenged its exclusion, and the Single Judge awarded ₹5 lakh compensation.

Issue: Whether a bidder can be disqualified for violating a condition that was never prescribed in the tender notice.

Decision: A Division Bench of Justice Anil Kumar Sinha and Justice Vikash Kumar dismissed the State’s appeal and upheld the ₹5 lakh compensation. It held that the authorities acted arbitrarily by imposing an undisclosed condition. The Court also clarified that compensation was appropriate because the subsequent public work was substantially completed and disturbing the contract would cause further disruption.

Facts: The dispute concerned 18 kathas and 10 dhurs of land in Mainpura, Patna, acquired by the State Government in 1976 for constructing a drain. Compensation had not been paid to the original owner or her successor, Meira Kumar. Subsequently, the Collector cancelled the petitioner’s Jamabandi under Section 4(h) of the Bihar Land Reforms Act, 1950.

Issue: Whether the Collector could cancel the Jamabandi without establishing that the land had vested in the State and whether the petitioner was entitled to compensation under the 2013 Land Acquisition Act.

Decision: Justice Khatim Reza quashed the Collector’s order, holding that Section 4(h) could not be invoked without establishing statutory vesting. The Court restored the Jamabandi and recognised the petitioner’s entitlement to compensation under the 2013 Act.

Facts: Criminal proceedings were initiated against an advocate in connection with a legal opinion provided by him. The allegation was that the legal advice was incorrect and had resulted in consequences for the concerned parties.

Issue: Whether an advocate can face criminal prosecution merely because a legal opinion subsequently turns out to be incorrect.

Decision: The Patna High Court held that an advocate cannot be criminally prosecuted merely for giving an incorrect legal opinion. Criminal liability requires evidence of the necessary criminal intention and participation in an offence; an erroneous professional opinion alone does not establish criminal wrongdoing.

Join our WhatsApp Groups ( Click Here) and Telegram Channel ( Click Here) and get instant notifications