
1. Smt. Nirmala Devi (Since Deceased) v. Punjab National Bank and 3 Others
Facts: Smt. Nirmala Devi obtained an eviction decree against Punjab National Bank on 27 August 2012 concerning premises in Meerut. After her death, her legal successor initiated execution proceedings. However, Meerut Sahkari Awas Samiti Limited filed an objection under Order XXI Rule 97 CPC, delaying delivery of possession.
Issue: Whether the High Court could direct the executing court to decide the pending objection within a specified period by exercising supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution.
Decision: The Court directed the executing court to decide the objection within three months and subsequently consider the application for delivery of possession. It clarified that the merits of the objection and parties’ rights must be independently decided.
Also Read – Most Important Punjab and Haryana High Court Judgments of October 2026
2. Sanjay Tripathi @ Sanjay Kumar Tripathi v. State of U.P. and Another
Facts: The appellant, accused in a property dispute involving alleged fabrication of documents and illegal possession, sought a second bail application after spending approximately one year in custody. He argued that the trial was nearing completion and his release was necessary to collect defence evidence and ensure a fair trial.
Issue: Whether the right to prepare an effective defence and the advanced stage of trial independently justify granting bail in a successive bail application.
Decision: The Allahabad High Court rejected the second bail application, holding that the right to prepare an effective defence is relevant but cannot automatically justify bail. The accused must demonstrate specific circumstances requiring release. The Court directed the trial court to conclude the trial expeditiously without unnecessary adjournments.
Also Read – Most Important Madras High Court Judgments of October 2026
3. Cholamandalam M.S General Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Shakuntala And 4 Others
Facts: The case arose from a motor accident dated 12 November 2016 in which Champa died. Her three married daughters filed a compensation claim. The Motor Accident Claims Tribunal awarded ₹24,86,912 with 7% annual interest. The insurance company challenged the award, arguing that the daughters were not financially dependent on their deceased mother.
Issue: Whether married daughters who are legal representatives but are not financially dependent on the deceased are entitled to compensation under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.
Decision: The Allahabad High Court partly allowed the appeal and reduced compensation from ₹24,86,912 to ₹50,000 under Section 140, to be divided equally among the three daughters.
4. Rajeshwari Devi And Others Vs. Hari Shankar Pandey And Another
Facts: Hari Shankar Pandey filed a suit challenging Rajeshwari Devi’s status as the widow of Vindhyachal Pandey and the legitimacy of Shiv Sagar and Shiv Kumar as sons and legal heirs of Ram Awadh Pandey. The Trial Court accepted the allegations, relying mainly on an earlier maintenance order under Section 488 CrPC.
Issue: Whether an alleged illicit relationship could deprive a woman of her status as a widow and whether an earlier maintenance proceeding could conclusively establish the illegitimacy of children.
Decision: The High Court allowed the appeal, set aside the Trial Court’s decree and dismissed the suit. It held that an alleged subsequent relationship does not extinguish widowhood, and illegitimacy must be established through legally sufficient evidence. The earlier maintenance order was not conclusive proof of marital status or parentage.
5. Zakir And 4 Others Vs. Bundu And 5 Others
Facts: The original plaintiff, Bundu, filed an eviction suit against tenant Mohd. Afaq concerning a shop. During the proceedings, Bundu died on 23 May 2023, and his legal representatives applied for substitution on 18 July 2023. The tenants challenged the application, arguing that it was filed beyond the one-month limitation prescribed under Rule 25 of the U.P. Urban Buildings Rules, 1972.
Issue: Whether substitution of the deceased plaintiff’s legal representatives was governed by the one-month period under Rule 25 or the 90-day period under Article 120 of the Limitation Act, 1963.
Decision: The Allahabad High Court held that Order XXII CPC and Article 120 of the Limitation Act applied. Since the application was filed within 90 days, the suit had not abated. The Court dismissed the petition under Article 227.
6. Arvind Kumar Yadav (Corpus) & Another v. State of U.P. & Others
Facts: The case concerned the alleged unlawful detention of an innocent family member by police officers to pressurise another person accused of an offence to surrender.
Issue: Whether police can detain a family member who is not accused of any offence to compel the accused to surrender.
Decision: The Allahabad High Court held that the police cannot unlawfully detain innocent family members to put pressure on an accused person. Such detention violates personal liberty and constitutional protections. A Division Bench of Justice Atul Sreedharan and Justice Divesh Chandra Samant awarded ₹40,000 compensation to the affected person. The judgment reinforces that police investigation must remain within constitutional and statutory limits, and that relatives cannot be used as instruments of coercion.
7. Rekha Saxena and Another v. Roman Catholic Diocese Allahabad Pvt. Ltd. and Another
Facts: The dispute concerned possession of immovable property after a sale deed had been cancelled by a court decree. The occupants continued to remain in possession, while the opposite party sought to rely on the cancellation decree to obtain possession.
Issue: Whether cancellation of a sale deed, without an express direction for eviction or delivery of possession, authorises the decree-holder to dispossess the occupant.
Decision: The Allahabad High Court held that cancellation of a sale deed alone does not permit forcible dispossession. A separate decree for possession or eviction is necessary. It further observed that long and settled possession can establish a prima facie case for temporary injunction, even where the occupant’s title document has been cancelled. The judgment reinforces the principle that possession must be recovered through due process of law.
Join our WhatsApp Groups ( Click Here) and Telegram Channel ( Click Here) and get instant notifications
