
Facts of the case
DBS Bank Limited Singapore was the appellant, and Ruchi Soya Industries Limited and the Committee of Creditors (CoC) were the respondents. DBS Bank had lent about USD 50 million to Ruchi Soya. The loan was secured by charges over immovable assets in Gujarat, Rajasthan and Madhya Pradesh. In December 2017, Ruchi Soya entered the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP), and DBS Bank’s claim of Rs. 242.96 crore was admitted. Patanjali Ayurveda later offered a plan to take over and run Ruchi Soya, in return for paying a fixed total amount to the lenders. Patanjali was the successful resolution applicant, and its plan was approved by the CoC. DBS Bank was offered only Rs. 64.24 crore under the plan. DBS voted against the plan, but most of the other lenders voted in favour, so the plan was approved. DBS considered the result unfair, as its security was worth much more. It challenged the distribution before the NCLT and then the NCLAT. After its challenge was dismissed, it approached the Supreme Court.
Also Read – Is Seeking Information a Crime, or An Act of Exposing Corruption?
Issues Raised
1.What is the minimum amount a dissenting financial creditor is entitled to receive under Section 30(2)(b)(ii) of the IBC?
2.Can the majority of the Committee of Creditors override a dissenting lender’s right over its secured property, relying on its commercial wisdom?
3 Does the 2019 amendment to Section 30(2)(b)(ii) apply to this case, where the insolvency process began in 2017?
Also Read – Section 101 BNS: Murder Explained with Landmark Cases
Arguments
DBS Bank (appellant)
DBS argued that the 2019 amendment applied to its case, because its appeal was still pending before the NCLAT when the law was amended.
DBS said the other creditors, who had weaker security, were getting an unfair benefit by sharing the money equally, while DBS did not receive the amount it deserved.
DBS said that if it enforced its security, it would recover about 90% of its exposure, so it should get at least the value of its own security.
DBS argued that the majority cannot take away a dissenting creditor’s legal protection under Section 30(2)(b)(ii) of the IBC.
Also Read – Bihar APO Exam 2026 Prelims Law Question Paper (Complete Questions)
Ruchi Soya and the Committee of Creditors (respondents)
They argued that the money should be distributed pro rata among all creditors, as per the plan approved by the Committee of Creditors.
The Committee of Creditors has the power to decide how the money is distributed, as this is a matter of its commercial wisdom.
They relied on the Amit Metaliks judgment. There, the Supreme Court held that a dissenting secured financial creditor is entitled only to the amount allotted to it under the resolution plan. Even if it can enforce its security, its recovery is limited to that allotted amount.
Judgment
The Supreme Court considered the dispute between DBS Bank and the Committee of Creditors (CoC) over how the money under Patanjali’s resolution plan was to be distributed. It held that the 2019 amendment to Section 30(2)(b)(ii) applied to the case. It interpreted the provision to mean that a dissenting financial creditor is entitled to receive at least the minimum amount it would receive in liquidation under Section 53(1), which the Court read as the value of its security interest. The Court emphasised that the commercial wisdom of the CoC must be respected, but it cannot be used to take away the minimum statutory protection given to dissenting financial creditors.
However, this interpretation differed from the earlier judgment in India Resurgence ARC v. Amit Metaliks. Therefore, the Court referred the legal question to a larger bench instead of finally deciding it.
Conclusion
The Supreme Court held that the 2019 amendment applied to DBS’s case, and that a dissenting financial creditor is entitled to at least the value of its security interest under Section 30(2)(b)(ii). It accepted that the Committee of Creditors’ commercial wisdom must be respected, but said this cannot remove that minimum protection. Because this view differed from India Resurgence ARC v. Amit Metaliks, the Court referred the question to a larger bench instead of finally deciding it.
Join our WhatsApp Groups ( Click Here) and Telegram Channel ( Click Here) and get instant notifications
