In this case, the Supreme Court examined the scope of Section 304B of the IPC / Section 80 of the BNS, read with Section 2 of the Dowry Prohibition Act, 1961, and the mandatory presumption under Section 113B of the Indian Evidence Act / Section 118 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam. The Court clarified that a conviction for dowry death does not require proof of a formal agreement at the time of marriage. It also explained the “proximity test” for determining whether the cruelty or harassment connected with dowry demands occurred “soon before” the woman’s death.

Also Read – Vijay Shankar Pandey v. Union of India (2014) Explained

Satwant Kaur (Bholi), married Baldev Singh on June 8, 1991. Within a month solemnisation of  marriage, the accused (Baldev Singh), started making demands for fridge or TV from the Satwant Kaur, hereinafter the victim or deceased, the initial demand when meet ignited the series of the same, to which Rachhpal Singh (PW-4) initially paid 20,000 rupees on two separate occasions to pacify in laws. Unperturbed, the in laws and her husband constant abused her, with an additional demand for Rs. 1,00,000 in cash as a share in his father-in-law estate, in distress she consumed Organo- Phosphorus on 3 September, 1992. Now, during the series of dowry demand Bholi sent multiple letters to her brother, Rachhpal Singh (PW-4). Before dying that day at Guru Nanak Dev Hospital, she told PW-4 that the accused had beaten her for failing to bring more money, leading to appellant’s conviction for dowry death under section 304 of IPC/105 BNS.

Also Read – 50 Landmark Supreme Court Judgments Every Law Student Must Know

  1. Whether an express agreement is required at the time of the marriage to constitute “dowry” under section 304, IPC/ 105 BNS read with section 2 of the Dowry prohibition act, 1961.
  2. Whether the demand of ancestral property would constitute to solely shared in the property or was it just an independent dowry demand?
  3. Whether under sec 113B of the IEA/118 BSAwould be triggered?

Also Read – Section 80 BNS: Dowry Death – Essential Ingredients, Punishment & Legal Provisions

  1. The primary legal question raised by the appellant here is very definition of dowry under section2 of the Dowry Prohibition Act, 1961, which was incorporated by section 304B IPC / 105 BNS for which appellant contended as never make a formal agreement, for the “agreed to be given”, clause  under the section at the time of the marriage. The supreme court relied on the Pawan Kumar precedent to support their conclusion, reasoned that the demand in the section 304B IPC/105 BNS penalises the dowry act itself, and the demand made at anytime of the marriage which does not require any pre existing agreement, to hold this would made ease for perpetrator to escape the crime and defeat the entire objective of legislation. The court established that the post-marriage demand for valuable security can be inferred directly or indirectly from the surrounding circumstances without proving a prior contract.
  2. The court analysed that because dowry related violence and harassment typically occur within the closed confines of matrimonial homes, which makes it difficult for the prosecution to secure the eyewitnesses testimony, due to the direct influence of the close bond. To remedify this and fill this gap Parliament enacted Section 113B IEA/118 BSA to create a mandatory “presumption of law”. The court reasoned once the prosecution rules out the death to e unnatural death within the 7years of marriage and furtherance to that the victim was subjected to cruelty and harassment in connection with dowry demand, which leaves no room for and presume that the accused caused the dowry death.
  3. The court clarifies that the expression “soon before her death” does not refer to any fixed period of time. It meaning depends upon the facts and the circumstance of each case, drawing a direct analogy to the phrase “soon after” under Section 114 Illustration (a) IEA/120 BSA, and the court formulated the proximity test, which dictates that there must be link that connects the death with the reasons. If for example an incident occurred way before in a remote past, and which have no direct link to the demise would not constitute the dowry death. In this case the death occurred connected to the demands and the analysis of the evidence could be drove with the letters written by the victim herself, and her oral statement to her brother on 3 September morning, drew the direct link between her suicide and the reasons. Also taking the issue, whether the demands for a woman right in her ancestral homes or her legitimate shares per se not dowry, but drawing the inference from the case at hand and the material evidence and the testimonies, it was established these demands were accompanied by continuous harassment. Therefore, court rejected the appellants defence that the dispute concerned only the ancestral property and upheld this conviction under the dowry death.

Join our WhatsApp Groups ( Click Here) and Telegram Channel ( Click Here) and get instant notifications

Download Pdf – Baldev Singh v. State of Punjab, (2008) 13 SCC 233