
Overview
The supreme court highlights the section 197 of code of criminal procedure 1973 it provide protection to public servant against prosecution for acts performed their official duties without prior government sanction this case from allegation of conspiracy forgery and manipulation of land records by city survey officer in Dhule Maharashtra the Bombay high court had quashed the criminal proceeding the ground prior sanction was required before prosecuting the accused public servant then supreme court by Ashok it examines the alleged acts of forgery and manipulation of official property records considered part of the officer official duties it highlights section 197 CRPC/218 BNSS not provide blanket immunity to public servant for alleged criminal acts that have reasonable connection with their official responsibilities the court set aside the Bombay high court order and restored the criminal proceeding reinforcing the principle of accountability of public servant and preventing misuse of legal protection.
Background
The appellant Ashok raised allegation against a city survey officer Mahesh fulpagre and another individual for allegedly conspiring to prepare and use forged document to manipulate property records alleged that actions resulted in an incorrect mutation entry and the removal of a charitable trust name from the relevant property criminal investigation were conducted and charge sheet were filed against the accused under various provision of Indian penal code in offence relating to cheating forgery and criminal conspiracy the accused public servant challenged the criminal proceeding for government sanction under section 197 Crpc/218BNSS before prosecution the Bombay high court accepted the requirement of prior sanction for criminal proceeding aggrieved by this Ashok approached the supreme court India challenging the high court order the supreme court was requires to determine whether the alleged acts forgery and manipulation of land records were sufficient connected with the discharge of official duties to attract the protection of section 197 CRPC/218 BNSS
Relevant legal provision
| Sections IPC | Sections BNS | Offence |
| Section 420 | Section 318(4) | Cheating and dishonesty |
| Section 465 | Section 336(2) | Punishment for forgery |
| Section 466 | Section 337 | Forgey of public records |
| Section 468 | Section 336(3) | Forgery for the purpose of cheating |
| Section 471 | Section 340(2) | Using forged document as genuine |
| Section 474 | deleted | possession of forged document |
| Section 120B | Section 61(2) | Criminal conspiracy |
| Section 34 | Section 3(5) | Common intention |
Court observation
Court observed Protection under section 197 CRPC public servants against false or prosecution for act to their official duties the court clarifies the alleged act must have reasonable and direct connection the official duties of public servant having opportunity to commit an offence because of one official position is not sufficient to claim protection conspiring to prepare forged document presenting them as genuine and manipulating property records to fraudulent transfer cannot be considered acts performed in the discharge of official duties the public servant cannot misuse the protection granted under section 197 CRPC to conceal criminal activities committed under the color of public offence.
Conclusion
The supreme court of India reaffirmed that the protection granted to public servant under section 197 of CRPC it clarifies the act of forgery , fabrication of document and manipulation of property records cannot automatically be considered part of official duties set aside the Bombay high court order and restoring the criminal proceedings the supreme court strengthen the accountability , transparency and equality before law the judgement make it clear that public office cannot be misused as shield against criminal liability the no public servant is above law.
Join our WhatsApp Groups ( Click Here) and Telegram Channel ( Click Here) and get instant notifications
Download PDF – Ashok vs Mahesh & Anr. (2026 INSC 1235)
