In Surendra Prasad Tiwari v. State of Bihar & Ors., the Patna High Court dismissed a Letters Patent Appeal challenging the rejection of an employee’s claim for counting his earlier service under centrally sponsored education schemes towards seniority and promotional benefits in a regular government cadre. The Division Bench of Justice Mohit Kumar Shah and Justice Sourendra Pandey held that temporary or ad hoc service under a scheme does not, by itself, become service in the regular establishment of the State Government. Where the subsequent absorption is expressly treated as a fresh appointment, past service cannot be used to claim seniority or promotional benefits contrary to the terms of absorption.

The appellant was initially appointed on 29 June 1985 for three months, on a temporary and ad hoc basis, as an Accounts Clerk under the Adult Education Scheme. His engagement continued through extensions and his subsequent placement in another centrally sponsored Non-Formal Education Scheme. That scheme was closed with effect from 31 March 2001, and his services were terminated from 1 April 2001. In 2006, the State absorbed him in the Welfare Department as a Clerk-cum-Accountant/Clerk-cum-Typist. The absorption orders expressly treated the appointment as a new appointment: earlier service would not confer seniority or other service benefits, although it would be counted for pension. The appellant sought recognition of his service from 1985 for seniority and promotion. A Single Judge dismissed his writ petition in 2023, leading to the present appeal.

The judgment principally interprets the conditions contained in the State Government’s absorption orders dated 10 February 2006 and 20 July 2006. It does not rest its conclusion on a particular statutory provision. The Bench applied established Supreme Court principles on scheme-based employment. In Mohd. Abdul Kadir v. Director General of Police, Assam, (2009) 6 SCC 611, the Supreme Court held that temporary or ad hoc employment linked to a project or scheme ordinarily ends when that project or scheme closes and does not create an entitlement to regularisation. The Patna High Court also considered State of Bihar v. Baliram Singh, (2018) 18 SCC 46; Parmeshwar Nanda v. State of Jharkhand, (2020) 12 SCC 131; Dhyan Singh v. State of Haryana, (2002) 10 SCC 656; and other decisions concerning employment under temporary schemes and the effect of fresh absorption.

The Court observed that the appellant’s initial appointment was expressly temporary and ad hoc and was connected to centrally sponsored schemes rather than a permanent post in the State Government’s regular cadre. The closure of the schemes therefore brought the scheme-based engagement to an end. The Bench further held that the appellant entered the regular cadre only upon his absorption in 2006. Since the absorption orders described that absorption as a new appointment and specifically excluded seniority and other benefits based on past service, he could not claim that his cadre seniority should run from 1985. The Court also noted that granting him earlier seniority could adversely affect existing employees who had entered the relevant cadre before him. The earlier service was, however, recognised for pension in accordance with the express terms of the absorption orders.

The Patna High Court found no error in the Single Judge’s decision or in the 2006 absorption orders and dismissed the appeal. The judgment clarifies that long service under a government-sponsored scheme does not automatically create a right to regular cadre status, seniority or promotion. The terms on which an employee is subsequently absorbed are crucial. For law students, judiciary aspirants and service-law practitioners, the decision is a useful illustration of the distinction between scheme-based engagement and regular government service, and of the legal consequences of absorption as a fresh appointment.

Download Pdf – Surendra Prasad Tiwari v. State of Bihar & Ors. 2026