
Overview
On 18 November 2026, the Bombay High Court set aside the sanction given by ICICI Bank’s board of directors to prosecute its former MD and CEO, Chanda Kochhar, in the Videocon loan case. The Court held that the board was not the authority who could grant sanction under Section 19 of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. It also found that the sanction order was passed without proper application of mind. The ruling matters to anyone studying or practising criminal law, because prosecution sanction is a point on which many cases get stuck.
Also Read – Javed v. State of Haryana (2003): Two-Child Norm and Constitutional Validity
Background
The CBI case is that Kochhar, while heading ICICI Bank, helped the Videocon Group get loans between June 2009 and October 2011, even though her husband had business dealings with the group’s promoter, Venugopal Dhoot. As per the CBI, she received about ₹64 crore as illegal gratification through a company linked to her husband after a ₹300 crore loan was sanctioned to Videocon International Electronics Limited, and the bank lost ₹1,033.39 crore. Kochhar denies these allegations.
The bank’s board granted sanction on 15 May 2023. Kochhar challenged it in the High Court. Her main argument was that under the Banking Regulation Act, the RBI controls the removal of a bank’s managing director, so only the RBI could sanction her prosecution.
Also Read – Doctrine of Attribution: How Courts Determine a Company’s Criminal Intent
Legal Provisions
Section 19 of the PC Act says a court cannot take cognisance of certain offences against a public servant unless there is previous sanction from the authority competent to remove that person from office. Sections 35B and 36AA of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949 give the RBI the power over appointment and removal of a bank’s managing director and other whole-time directors. The CBI, on the other hand, relied on the usual position that a company’s board manages its senior officers.
Observations of the Court
The Court accepted Kochhar’s argument and held that the power to sanction her prosecution lay with the RBI. According to the Court, the Banking Regulation Act overrides the Companies Act and a bank’s own internal arrangements when it comes to appointing and removing top management, so the board could not use powers that belong to the RBI.
The CBI said the validity of sanction can be checked during trial. The Court did not agree. It said that whether the sanctioning authority was legally competent is a question of jurisdiction, and it can be decided at the very start.
The Court also looked at the sanction order itself. It only mentioned allegations of bribery and corruption and did not discuss witness statements, documents or any other material against Kochhar. It seemed the board went by the CBI’s report and request, without checking the evidence on its own. The Court further noted that the bank’s own position, recorded in the order and the board minutes, was that its policies were not violated while giving the loans and it suffered no wrongful loss.
In the end the Court quashed the sanction and everything that followed it before the Special CBI Court. The CBI asked for the judgment to be stayed for eight weeks so that it could appeal, but the Court refused.
Conclusion
The judgment is a good reminder of two basic rules on sanction. First, it must come from the authority that can actually remove the accused. Second, that authority must look at the material and form its own view, not just sign on the investigating agency’s report. For private bank officers, the decision shows that the Banking Regulation Act can decide who gives sanction. Law students and judiciary aspirants should note that a defect in sanction was treated as a threshold issue here. Advocates in PC Act cases can check competence and application of mind early. The CBI may still approach a higher court, and the detailed order should be read once it is available, as this note is based on news reports of the judgment.
Join our WhatsApp Groups ( Click Here) and Telegram Channel ( Click Here) and get instant notifications
